The Antiques Roadshow Controversy: Are Trainers the New Antiques?

The BBC’s beloved show, Antiques Roadshow, has long been a staple of British television, captivating audiences with its fascinating insights into the history and value of various collectibles. However, a recent episode has sparked a heated debate among fans, as the inclusion of a collection of modern sports trainers has left many questioning the definition of an antique.

A New Episode, A New Controversy

In a recent episode aired on a Sunday, host Fiona Bruce and expert James Broad visited London’s Pitzhanger Manor and Gallery. The episode featured a guest who presented a striking collection of Nike trainers, which he claimed was part of a larger assortment of 40 to 50 pairs he owned. Broad, known for his expertise in the field, expressed his excitement over the collection, stating, "You have absolutely made my day with these. These are an incredible collection."

The trainers, dating from 2003 to the present, were described by the guest as having a significant backstory, including a limited release of just 250 pairs sold in a single New York store. Broad’s enthusiasm was palpable as he examined the shoes, noting their pristine condition and rarity. He confidently appraised the collection at a staggering £12,000 to £18,000, suggesting that their value would only increase over time.

The Definition of an Antique

While Broad’s appraisal may have delighted the guest, it left many viewers perplexed. Traditionally, antiques are defined as objects that are at least 100 years old. This long-standing definition has been the cornerstone of the antiques market, leading many to question whether modern trainers can truly be classified as antiques.

Social media erupted with comments from frustrated fans. One viewer tweeted, "I was under the impression that the generally accepted definition of an antique is ‘An object more than 100 years old.’ Trainers? Really?" Another chimed in, "Since when were trainers antiques for f sake – p off and take your trainers with you!" The sentiment was clear: many felt that the inclusion of such contemporary items diluted the essence of what Antiques Roadshow represents.

The Evolution of Collectibles

The debate surrounding the trainers highlights a broader conversation about the evolution of collectibles and what constitutes value in today’s market. As society progresses, so too does the definition of what is considered collectible. Items that were once dismissed as mere consumer goods can gain historical significance over time, particularly if they are tied to cultural movements or significant events.

In recent years, the sneaker culture has exploded, with limited-edition releases and collaborations becoming highly sought after. Collectors are willing to pay exorbitant prices for rare models, and the market for vintage sneakers has grown exponentially. This shift in consumer behavior raises questions about the future of collecting and whether items like trainers should be included in discussions about antiques.

Viewer Reactions: A Mixed Bag

The mixed reactions from viewers reflect the tension between tradition and modernity. While some fans expressed their discontent, others defended the inclusion of trainers, arguing that the show should adapt to changing times. One viewer noted, "Why, oh why, oh why are we seeing modern footwear on the #antiquesroadshow?" while another commented, "Plimsolls on #antiquesroadshow? It has officially gone to the dogs. I’m out."

This division among fans underscores the challenge faced by Antiques Roadshow in balancing its rich history with the evolving landscape of collectibles. As the show continues to feature a diverse range of items, it must navigate the fine line between honoring traditional definitions and embracing contemporary trends.

Conclusion: A New Era for Antiques?

The inclusion of modern trainers on Antiques Roadshow has ignited a passionate debate about the nature of antiques and collectibles. As society evolves, so too does our understanding of value and significance in the world of collecting. While some viewers may resist this change, it is clear that the definition of what constitutes an antique is becoming increasingly fluid.

As we move forward, it will be interesting to see how Antiques Roadshow adapts to these changes and whether it will continue to feature items that challenge our traditional notions of antiques. For now, the trainers may have sparked controversy, but they have also opened the door to a broader conversation about the future of collecting in an ever-changing world.